Statistics don’t care about opinions.

65 SPY Strategies

Black Friday offer

If you want to run the tests in this article yourself, paid subscribers get the exact entry and exit rules, indicator settings, and backtests (plus hundreds of other strategies).

65 SPY trading strategies

This guide brings 65 strategy profiles together so you can compare the signals, holding periods, and risks before deciding which to research.

SPY is the ticker for the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust. It tracks the S&P 500, and its fund history starts in January 1993. A test using SPY prices can differ from a test using the S&P 500 cash index, ES futures or a leveraged ETF. For the fund’s objective and official details, see the State Street SPY fund page.

SPY trading strategies at a glance

  • RSI pullback with a previous-high exit · 388 trades · 77% winners · 0.80% average trade · 23% maximum drawdown

  • Three down closes and a one-session hold · 714 trades · 62% winners · 0.26% average trade · 17% maximum drawdown

  • Normalized RSI pullback · 426 trades · 75% winners · 0.50% average trade · 14% maximum drawdown

  • Turn of the month with a moving-average filter · 167 trades · 67% winners · 1.20% average trade · 15% maximum drawdown

Figures are from the linked backtests. The guide includes published backtests and setups to test further.

Follow the individual studies for entry and exit details, test assumptions and equity curves where available.

Their execution assumptions and test windows can differ. A high win rate can coexist with large losses, so check the average winner, average loser and the equity curve alongside the win percentage. Please backtest yourself.

Find a SPY strategy by trading style

  • Mean reversion and pullbacks: Strategies 1–27

  • Price action and candlestick patterns: Strategies 28–33

  • Overnight, calendar and event trades: Strategies 34–47

  • Day trading, volatility and market signals: Strategies 48–56

  • Pairs, rotation and portfolio strategies: Strategies 57–65

Mean reversion and pullbacks

1. RSI pullback with a previous-high exit

A sharply oversold RSI reading can flag a promising dip, but it doesn’t tell you when the rebound has run its course.

This setup buys weakness and waits for SPY to close above the previous session’s high (the QS Exit). The close-entry test averaged 0.8% per trade, dropping to 0.6% with entry at the next open. That difference shows how much of the rebound can occur before the next opening bell. R

2. Normalized RSI pullback

An RSI reading that looks ordinary in one market can be unusually low in another.

This setup measures RSI against its own recent range to find weakness relative to recent conditions. The published SPY test recorded 426 trades, with 75% winners and a 14% maximum drawdown. It’s a good example of how an adaptive signal can make a familiar indicator behave differently.

3. Deep pullback above the 200-day average

When SPY is above its 200-day average, a sharp selloff can create a pullback within a longer uptrend. That’s the situation this setup looks for.

The historical test held a position only about 5% of the time. That makes it worth comparing the average trade with the rate at which the strategy actually finds opportunities.

4. Stochastic pullback in a rising trend

The stochastic oscillator shows where SPY closes within its recent high-to-low range. A weak reading in a rising market can flag a dip after a stretch of stronger prices.

The published test had a 14% maximum drawdown. Compare it with the RSI setups to see whether the two indicators find different pullbacks or mostly buy on the same days.

5. New high followed by weakness

A fresh high tells you SPY has shown strength. This setup waits for a weak finish afterward, giving the trader a chance to buy a dip after that strength.

The original study reported about 0.4% per trade on average. If you reproduce it, compare the signal close and the next open, since a small difference in entry price can matter at that scale.

6. Commodity Channel Index pullback

The Commodity Channel Index measures how far price has moved from its recent average. Here the idea is to buy unusual weakness and look for a recovery.

The SPY test was invested 28% of the time and had a 23% maximum drawdown. That makes it an interesting comparison with normalized RSI, which also measures unusual weakness but uses a different input.

7. RSI pullback with two moving averages

Two moving averages give this setup a way to identify the broader trend and the shorter pullback. RSI then helps decide whether the dip is deep enough to act on.

The original test entered at the next open and spent about 8% of the time invested. Pay particular attention to how the time limit is counted if you reproduce the results.

8. Larry Connors’ R3

Larry Connors’ R3 looks for short-term RSI weakness that builds across several sessions. The idea is to wait for continued selling before looking for a rebound.

If you already trade a short RSI setup, compare the entry dates. Two rules with different names can still leave you holding almost the same positions.

9. Larry Connors’ Double Seven

Double Seven uses recent highs and lows to turn a pullback and its recovery into price-based signals. For someone used to RSI, it offers a straightforward comparison.

You can see how much changes when you define weakness by a rolling price extreme and let a new high help determine when to exit.

10. Chande Momentum Oscillator strategy

The Chande Momentum Oscillator compares recent upward and downward moves. It can help you express the question in concrete terms. Has selling recently outweighed buying by enough to consider a trade? The published test used dividend-adjusted SPY data, so match that adjustment when comparing your own results.

11. Five-day closing-low pullback

A five-day closing low marks a stretch of weakness using prices at the end of the session. Using closes matters. SPY can fall below an intraday low and then recover by the close, leaving this version without a signal. Compare the two definitions to see which trades are unique to each.

12. Monday IBS pullback

This setup focuses on Mondays when SPY finishes near the bottom of its daily range. Internal Bar Strength, or IBS, expresses that closing location as a number. The exit allows the trade to end on a rebound or a time limit. That gives you a way to see whether the rebound usually comes quickly or needs several sessions.

13. Mean-reversion band and IBS

A dip below a range-based band tells you price has moved unusually far. A low IBS tells you SPY also closed near the day’s low. Combining the two looks for weakness on both measures. The source exits after a close above the previous day’s high, which gives the rebound an observable price target.

14. Monday weakness

Here the weakness has to build over two sessions. The setup buys the Monday close and waits for a close above the previous high to exit.

Compare those trades with a simpler Monday-drop rule to see whether requiring a weak Friday changes the quality of the signal.

15. Volatility contraction within a trend

A narrow session in an uptrend can give you a defined entry condition without having to guess when the next large move will occur. The original setup pairs the contraction with a price-based exit. Try comparing narrow sessions inside and outside a rising trend to see how much the trend requirement changes the result.

16. Classic IBS plus RSI

IBS measures the close within the current day’s range, while RSI summarizes recent moves across sessions. Both can flag weakness, but they describe different parts of the move. Test each signal alone and then together to see whether requiring both improves the average trade enough to justify fewer opportunities.

17. Connors %B pullback

Bollinger %B expresses the close’s position relative to the Bollinger Bands. Connors’ approach uses an unusually weak reading as a potential entry. Shorter band settings can respond more quickly to a selloff, so match the source settings before drawing conclusions from a comparison with RSI or Keltner Channels.

18. Connors high–low

Repeatedly lower highs and lows describe weakness that unfolds across several sessions. Connors’ method makes that sequence measurable and gives you a price-based alternative to RSI. Check which highs and lows the study includes in the sequence, since that detail determines when a setup first qualifies.

19. Multiple days up and down

A sequence of rising or falling days can tell a different story from a one-day price shock. This test turns the sequence into a signal that can be compared across many market periods. Pay attention to how the source handles interruptions, such as a flat close between two declining sessions.

20. Keltner Channel pullback

Keltner Channels use average true range to adjust the width of the envelope around price. The study describes a six-day setting and an ATR multiplier. That gives the pullback a definition that can expand in volatile markets and tighten in quieter ones. Compare how often it triggers in each environment.

21. Williams %R pullback

Williams %R compares the close with the high-to-low range over a recent lookback. The published study highlights a N-day version, making it sensitive to very recent weakness. If you already use short RSI, compare the signals on the same dates to understand what Williams %R adds.

22. Rubber Band Strategy

A large move away from recent price behavior can set up a rebound. The Rubber Band study applies its rules to SPY, QQQ and XLP, giving you a way to compare the same idea across different funds. Look at the trade counts and worst periods as well as the average return.

23. Choppiness Index setup

The Choppiness Index describes how much price has moved back and forth relative to the ground it covered. A reading that suggests choppy conditions can help frame whether you want to test a short-term reversal. This is a very underrated indicator, in our opinion. Use the source’s entry and exit to keep the strategy separate from the indicator itself.

24. Twenty-day EMA setup

A 20-day exponential moving average gives more weight to recent prices than a simple average of the same length. It reacts sooner when SPY changes direction, which can also produce more signals during a sideways period. Match the source’s dividend and split treatment when comparing backtests.

25. RSI range momentum

RSI can help identify persistent strength as well as oversold conditions. This strategy looks for a range of RSI readings associated with momentum. The SPY test recorded just 12 trades, so a few observations can move the headline statistics by a lot. The dates of those trades are worth studying individually.

26. RSI oversold threshold research

What happens if you test several oversold RSI thresholds rather than choosing one in advance? The answer can show whether an idea works across neighboring settings or depends on a narrow choice. Use the comparison to pick a specification for further testing, then evaluate it on a separate period.

27. Bear-market long and short

This study looks at taking long and short signals during market stress. Treat the two sides separately when evaluating results. Borrow costs, execution during volatile sessions and the size of gap moves can all change the economics of the short side.

Price action and candlestick patterns

28. Four consecutive up days

After four straight up days, is SPY more likely to keep going or give some of the gains back? A streak alone doesn’t tell you the answer. Compare the return after the fourth close with the return over an ordinary SPY session, and check how often unusually large moves shaped the average.

29. Outside-day follow-through

An outside day trades above the previous high and below the previous low. That describes an expanded range and leaves the direction of the next move open. This study measures the next session from its open to its close, so the result isolates daytime movement after the pattern.

30. Narrowest daily range

Some days have unusually little movement from high to low. This setup turns that quiet period into a measurable condition and tests what follows. Look at the average gain alongside the number of qualifying sessions, since frequent small gains can be sensitive to trading costs.

31. Doji near the session low

A Doji has an open and close that are close together. When that pair of prices sits near the session low, it adds information about where the market spent its final moments. Compare this filtered setup with all Dojis to see whether location makes a difference.

32. Three-pattern candlestick system

This test combines bearish engulfing, three outside down and bullish harami as alternative signals, then applies an exit rule to the resulting trades. Daily and weekly bars produce different opportunities. Look at the number of trades as well as the return before deciding which timeframe tells you more.

33. Narrow Range

NR7 flags the narrowest high-to-low range among seven sessions. It tells you that the market has compressed, leaving direction and trade timing to the remaining rules. Comparing the published exit with a fixed holding period can help explain where the historical result came from.

Overnight, calendar and event trades

34. Three down closes and a one-session hold

Three consecutive down closes create an easily defined test. Buy at the third close and measure what happens through the next session. The published SPY test logged 714 trades, with 62% winners, a 0.26% average gain and a 17% maximum drawdown. A modest average gain makes commissions and the price you actually get especially important.

35. Turnaround Tuesday after a weak Monday

A weak Monday sets up this trade, and Tuesday’s close gives it a fixed endpoint. That makes it easy to ask whether Tuesday actually behaves differently from other sessions after a drop. The study reported 212 trades, a 56% win rate and a 0.3% average gain. Compare it with a similar trade on other weekdays to see what the Monday filter adds.

36. Wednesday turnaround after Tuesday weakness

This setup starts with a weak Tuesday and gives the rebound several sessions to develop. The longer window can capture a recovery that takes time. It also leaves you exposed to several overnight gaps. Compare the holding-period distribution with the one-session Turnaround Tuesday setup before deciding which fits your trading schedule.

37. Turn of the month with a moving-average filter

The calendar identifies the days to watch around month-end, and a moving average helps determine whether a trade qualifies.

The test reported 167 trades, 67% winners, a 1.2% average gain and a 15% maximum drawdown. A useful follow-up is to test the same dates without the moving-average filter and see how much it contributes.

38. Overnight rebound after an unusually large drop

An unusually large decline can leave traders wondering whether the selling will continue overnight. This study measures SPY from that session’s close to the following open.

The definition of a large drop is central to the test. A stricter threshold selects rarer events and can make a few exceptional days dominate the result.

39. N-day low overnight

An N-day low can be followed by a bounce while the stock market is closed. This setup focuses on the overnight window. Its result can differ from a five-day-low swing trade because the next morning ends the exposure, even if the rebound continues during the day.

40. VIX, trend and price-action overnight

This close-to-close approach looks for a specific combination of volatility, trend and price action. That makes it a selective overnight trade. With about 10% exposure in the published study, it’s worth checking whether the signals are spread across market environments or concentrated in a few periods.

41. First trading day of the month

The first session of the month offers a calendar signal you can define ahead of time. Use the exchange calendar to find it, especially when a holiday shifts the first trading session. Compare the exact close-to-close window with neighboring sessions to see whether the timing matters.

42. Last trading day of the month

The final trading day of the month can behave differently from the broader turn-of-the-month window. This study isolates that one-day exposure. Check the instrument used for each part of the history before comparing the outcome with a SPY-only test.

43. Options expiration day

This test measures the return from Thursday’s close to expiration Friday’s close. The source found weak historical results for the long setup. That makes it a useful example of why an effect reported for an entire options-expiration week can look different when you isolate a single session.

44. Earnings-season window

Earnings season bundles a lot of company news into a recurring window. This strategy tests whether that timing is useful for the broad ETF. The published SPY results included 133 trades. Review how the window was defined so the same dates can be identified in a fresh test.

45. Nonfarm payrolls release window

A payroll release can move SPY sharply around the open. This setup studies a defined window around the event. Use the actual release dates and times, since rescheduled reports can affect the sample. It also helps to separate the pre-release exposure from moves that occur after the report.

46. Holiday effect

Market holidays change the trading calendar and sometimes shorten the preceding session. Define the days before and after each holiday precisely, then compare those windows with normal sessions. A result across many holidays may hide important differences between individual events.

47. Mean reversion with a seasonal filter

Start with a pullback rule, then restrict it to a calendar window. To see what the calendar contributes, compare the filtered and unfiltered trades over the same history. A stronger average trade can still come with a much smaller sample and longer stretches without a signal.

Day trading, volatility and market signals

48. Early-afternoon momentum into the close

The idea is to see whether strength already visible in the early afternoon continues into the close. This SPY test used five-minute bars and reported 342 trades over more than 28 years. The profit factor fell from 3.72 to about 3.46 when the test allowed $0.03 per share in round-trip friction. Check the time of the signal carefully if you reproduce it.

49. Last-hour low or high, then next-day reversal

Where SPY makes its high or low can matter as much as how the session finishes. This test buys the next open after a last-hour low and tests a short after a last-hour high. Both trades exit at 11:30 on the entry day. The setup is a simple way to compare early-session reversals following late buying or selling.

50. VIX breakout as a SPY signal

The VIX measures expected volatility, and a breakout can flag a change in market conditions. This strategy uses that move to time a trade in SPY.

When you test it, record when the VIX signal becomes observable and when SPY could actually be traded. A result based on prices from different times can give a misleading picture.

51. Trading-session trend following

Intraday trend following looks for directional movement that persists through the session. The SPY study tests signals and exits within the trading day. If you reproduce it, use the same session hours and include trading costs, since those choices can change the result of a high-turnover strategy.

52. Short-side day trade

This setup explores whether a short intraday trade can capture a specific kind of weakness. Look for SPY-specific results when reviewing the original research, particularly if the article discusses several instruments. A test that works on another market may have a different execution profile on SPY.

53. TRIN breadth signal

TRIN links advancing and declining shares with their trading volume. That gives you a way to measure selling or buying pressure across the market before taking a position in SPY. Confirm how the data vendor scales TRIN before comparing thresholds with the original study.

54. VIX futures and spot signal

VIX futures and the spot VIX can send different signals about current and expected volatility. This study uses volatility inputs to help time an SPY trade. In a reproduction, define the futures contract and rollover convention explicitly so the signal reflects information available at the time.

55. Volume-based SPY timing

A price move can look more meaningful when trading activity changes alongside it. This strategy turns that idea into a volume-based SPY signal. The published test includes commissions and slippage, which makes it useful to see how the average trade compares with the cost allowance.

56. Short-term Nasdaq and SPY allocation

The same short-term idea can produce different results on Nasdaq exposure and SPY. The study reports performance for SPY with dividends included. It’s a chance to see whether the timing rule depends on the behavior of one index or holds up across both.

Pairs, rotation and portfolio strategies

57. Overnight SPY and TLT pair

This pair holds SPY long and TLT short from one close to the next. What matters is how stocks perform relative to long-term Treasury bonds during that window. Position sizing determines how strongly each leg contributes. Include short-side costs and look at each leg separately so you can see where the returns came from.

58. Weekly rotation between SPY and XLV

This weekly strategy can hold either SPY or the healthcare ETF XLV. The appeal is easy to understand. Sometimes healthcare holds up better than the broad market. Both are stock funds, though, and the published test shows that moving into healthcare can still leave you exposed to prolonged equity weakness.

59. Weekly SPY and utilities rotation

This weekly strategy uses relative performance to switch between SPY and utilities. The defensive allocation is still equity exposure, so examine how it behaved during broad market declines. For very early periods, check whether the study used index proxies for either ETF.

60. SPY and gold rotation

This rotation compares the strength of stocks and gold, then uses the result to decide which market to hold. It can leave you outside SPY for extended periods. Compare those switches with buy-and-hold SPY to see how much of the outcome came from avoiding equity weakness versus holding gold.

61. SPY and TLT rotation

This setup switches between SPY and long-term Treasury bonds when the allocation rule changes. Unlike an overnight pair, it can spend extended periods holding just one market. Check what happened when stocks and bonds fell together, since defensive behavior can change across rate environments.

62. Three-equity-ETF rotation

The strategy compares SPY with developed international and emerging-market equities. Its purpose is to test whether switching among equity markets improves on holding SPY continuously. Review how often it trades and whether performance depends on a particular regional market cycle.

63. Five-ETF rotation

This rotation considers five ETFs across U.S. and international equities, Treasuries and gold. The broader universe provides more choices when SPY falls out of favor. To understand the equity curve, check how much time was spent in SPY and which alternatives carried the strongest or weakest periods.

64. Multi-asset trend following

This approach applies trend rules to several asset classes, with SPY as one of the positions it can hold. A smooth portfolio result can come from how the markets interact as much as from the SPY leg itself. Examine the individual positions and their overlap during difficult periods.

65. Donchian trend following across three assets

Donchian channels define breakouts using recent highs or lows. This study applies channel rules across SPY, Treasury bonds and gold. Compare the SPY portion with the combined portfolio to see which results came from the equity trend and which came from holding assets that moved differently.

Black Friday offer

See a setup you’d like to test? The full rules and settings for all 65 strategies are available for paying subscribers. If you’re not a paying subscriber, please use the Black Friday offer with a 40% discount.

How to compare SPY trading strategies

Start with the holding period you can actually trade. Close-to-close strategies, intraday strategies and weekly rotations place different demands on your execution. Next, compare the average trade with the full cost of trading. A strategy that shows 0.26% per trade has less room for imperfect fills than one with a larger average trade, all else equal.

Look beyond the headline win percentage and maximum drawdown. How long did the deepest drawdown last? Were there long stretches of flat results? Were most trades clustered in one market regime? Compare the curve with SPY buy-and-hold over the same dates, and look at market exposure so you can see how much time each approach put capital at risk.

If you plan to combine two strategies, compare their entry dates. Two pullback systems can look different on paper and still buy on the same days. Compare the overlap before treating them as independent sources of returns.

Frequently asked questions

What is a simple SPY strategy to backtest first?

Three down closes followed by a one-session hold is a useful starting point because the signal and exit can be stated in a few lines. Test the signal-close entry and the next available entry separately, then compare the result after costs.

Which SPY setup in the comparison had the lowest drawdown?

Among the four tests in the opening table, normalized RSI had the lowest reported maximum drawdown at 14%, followed by turn of the month at 15%. These are historical figures from separate source tests with potentially different assumptions.

Can these rules be used on SPX or ES?

You can test the same signals on those instruments, but the results can change. SPY is an ETF with dividends and its own trading prices. SPX is a cash index, and ES is a futures contract with different trading hours and rolls. Retest the instrument and session you plan to trade.

Historical results, not a forecast.

Best regards,
Oddmund Groette and Håkan Samuelsson

Best,

Oddmund Groette & Håkan Samuelsson

We appreciate the support! It means a lot!